This is pure gold. It is just about the perfect response to intellectual midgetry and its terrible assault on science, chemistry, soil science and critical thinking. As I said just gold!!
by BRIAN DUNNING, Nov 08 2012
It’s my favorite new logical fallacy, the “Appeal to Monsanto”, the world’s largest producer of biotech agriculture seeds. This is the logic that compels many anti-GMO activists to reply to any argument in support of biotech crops with “So you love Monsanto?”
It’s so wonderful because it combines many other logical fallacies into one, and is thus a great time saver. For example:
- It poisons the well (cloaks a viewpoint with negative weasel words) by associating the scary, evil word Monsanto.
- It’s a non-sequitur (a logical association that does not follow). IF (a) THEREFORE (b). IF (genes can be used to confer traits such as drought resistance) THEREFORE (I love Monsanto).
- It’s a straw man (misrepresenting what I said into something that’s easy to argue against). If I had actually said “I love Monsanto”, then plenty of rational arguments are available to show that’s…
View original post 1,430 more words